Bay Isles Homes For Sale | Longboat Key, FL

/ Neighborhoods / Bay Isles

Bay Isles Community Guide

Set in Longboat Key, Bay Isles is a golf course community with 1100 homes built 1976-2023.

Search 900+ Neighborhoods & Condos By Name

Bay Isles Real Estate in Longboat Key, FL

Bay Isles homes for sale sit inside a spectacular gated Longboat Key community about 3 miles north of Lido Key, more than 1,100 residences spread across 16 distinct neighborhoods. Entry runs behind a gate staffed 24 hours a day, giving residents a level of security and privacy that’s hard to match elsewhere on the island.

Home types run the full range, single family estates, condos, courtyard homes, villas, and townhouses, with single family sizes running 2,000 to nearly 7,000 square feet. Many bay side waterfront homes come with private boat docks, and homeownership includes membership to the private Bay Isles Beach Club on the Gulf. Longboat Key Club membership stays optional, with 45 holes of golf, tennis, a spa, and a 291-slip marina available if you want it.

Bay Isles Neighborhood Facts

510 Harbor Point Rd, Longboat Key, FL 34228, USA

Residences: 1100

Price Range:$900k-$10.0M
Year Built:1976 – 2023
Size (Sq. Ft.):2,091 – 6,556
Min. Lease:Varies By Neighborhood
Leases/ Year:Varies By Neighborhood
Gated:✔ Yes
Pool:✖ No
Fences:✖ No
Golf Course: ✔ Yes
CDD Fee:✖ No

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Amenities:

Tennis Courts, Swimming Pools, Lovely Walking Trails, Sidewalks, Membership to Bay Isles Beach Club.

Fees Include:

Fidelity Bond, Manager, Private Road, Recreational Facilities, Security, Trash Removal.

GET INSTANT

New Listing AlertS

Bay Isles

  • New listings move fast
  • Instant email alerts
  • Never miss a new listing

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

Honesty ยท Reputation ยท Experience ยท Top 2% Sales Team in Sarasota

Sarasota Homes Group The Best Sarasota Realtors

Map of Bay Isles

Map showing location of Bay Isles Homes For Sale | Longboat Key,
  FL
Click to explore map

Additional Bay Isles Neighborhood Information

Villas:

  • Harbour Circle
  • Harbour Oaks

Condominiums:

Bay Isles Frequently Asked Questions

Bay Isles Real Estate


How large is the Bay Isles neighborhood in Longboat Key?

Bay Isles is about 1100+ homes between 16 neighborhoods, built between 1970’s-Present.

Is Bay Isles in Longboat Key a gated community?

Yes, Bay Isles is a gated community.

What does Bay Isles homeownership include?

Homeownership includes membership to the private Bay Isles Beach Club, granting members access to the beach and lovely waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Optional membership is available to the Longboat Key Club, offering golf, tennis, fitness, and even a Marina with deep water slips for lease or purchase

Is Bay Isles in Longboat Key located in a golf community?

Yes, Bay Isles is located in a golf course community. Membership to the Longboat Key Club is optional. Amenities for the club include 45-holes of championship golf, 25 Har-Tru tennis courts, a Fitness Center, Spa, a Mind & Motion Studio, eight restaurants, 291 slip deep water marina, Camp Loggerhead for children ages 5 – 12, and the gorgeous Gulf of Mexico beach.

How far is Bay Isles from downtown Sarasota?

Bay Isles is located about 7.5 miles from downtown Sarasota.

What public beach is closest to Bay Isles?

Bay Isles is located about 1 mile from the Bay Isles Beach Club.

How far is the Sarasota International Airport from Bay Isles?

Bay Isles is located about 10.8 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.

Are pets allowed in Bay Isles?

Yes, it appears pets are allowed to some extent, however we recommend that you consult with a Realtor to get specific pet policy info for this community.

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Insight For Bay Isles

Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.

Bay Isles Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.
Sarasota Homes Group Logo

Our Personal Bay Isles Insights

Sarasota FL. Homes For Sale
"Pros" icon - Happy Face

Pros

  • A mix of villas, single homes, and condos are located here
  • Tremendous array of amenities
  • Secured gated community
traffic jam
"Cons" icon - Indifferent Face

Considerations

  • Some homes may be older and require some updating to suit buyer tastes
shopping district near UTC Mall
"Shopping" icon - Shopping Bag

Shopping

  • Grocery store is 1.1 miles
  • UTC Mall is 17.7 miles
  • Saint Armands Circle is 5.8 miles
Siesta Key Beach Residences Condos in Siesta Key, FL. - Beach
"Beach" icon - Beach and umbrella

Beach

  • Longboat Key is all private beach
  • Closest public beach access is Lido Key
  • Siesta Key Public Beach is 15.2 miles
Couple Outdoor Dining
"Lifestyle" icon - Fork & Knife

Lifestyle

  • Private beach/ country club type of lifestyle
  • Quiet surroundings
  • Marina with 291 boat slips can accommodate sail boats and large yachts
One Park Condos in Downtown Sarasota, FL - Exterior of Building at Sunset
"Downtown" icon - Downtown buildings

Downtown Sarasota

  • 9.8 miles
  • 22 minute drive

Explore Longboat Key FL. Neighborhoods

Compare Longboat Key communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.

More Details

Filter by community features:

1-12 of 22 Filtered Results
  • Bayou Hammock Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Bayou Hammock

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    15

    2,787 - 3,693

    1949 - 1989

    Varies By Neighborhood

    Varies By Neighborhood

    $2.5M-$5.5M

    Amenities:

    Privacy, Larger Lot Sizes, Waterfront.

    View Bayou Hammock Homes
  • Bayview Estates Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Bayview Estates

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    15

    1,704 - 4,106

    1951 - 2013

    1/Month

    12

    $1.3M-$5.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront.

    View Bayview Estates Homes
  • Conrad Beach Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Conrad Beach

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    27

    2,352 - 2,900

    1999 - 2020

    1 Month

    12

    $1.2M-$2.5M

    Amenities:

    Boat Launch, Community Clubhouse, Pool, Fishing Pier.

    View Conrad Beach Homes
  • Coreys Landing Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Corey's Landing

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    60

    2,206 - 4,510

    1989 - 1995

    1 Month

    2

    $1.0M-$4.0M

    Amenities:

    Deeded beach access to Bay Isles Beach Club, Gated, Golf Course Community, Tennis Courts, Pool.

    View Corey's Landing Homes
  • Country Club Shores Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Country Club Shores

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    745

    1,600 - 6,345

    1953 - 2023

    1 Month

    12

    $1.0M-$10.0M

    Amenities:

    Great canal front homes with Sarasota Bay views.

    View Country Club Shores Homes
  • Dream Island Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Dream Island

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    41

    1,295 - 5,203

    1946 - 2022

    1 Month

    12

    $515k-$4.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    View Dream Island Homes
  • Emerald Harbor Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Emerald Harbor

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    103

    1,929 - 4,022

    1951 - 2021

    1 Month

    12

    $1.5M-$5.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront, Deeded Private Beach Access, Deed Restrictions.

    View Emerald Harbor Homes
  • Emerald Pointe Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Emerald Pointe

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    26

    2,643 - 3,056

    1977 - 2003

    1 Month

    2

    $800k-$1.8M

    Amenities:

    Deeded beach access to Bay Isles Beach Club, Gated, Golf Community, Tennis Courts, Waterfront Complex.

    View Emerald Pointe Homes
  • Gulfshore of Longboat Key Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Gulfshore Of Longboat Key

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    100

    300 - 1,056

    1954 - 1995

    Not Permitted

    Not Permitted

    $95k-$300k

    Amenities:

    Pool, Clubhouse, 55+ Community.

    View Gulfshore Of Longboat Key Homes
  • Harbour Court Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Harbour Court

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    18

    2,462 - 3,252

    1987 - 1988

    3 Months

    4

    $825k-$2.0M

    Amenities:

    Deeded Beach Access, Gated, Tennis, Manicured Grounds, Bay front.

    View Harbour Court Homes
  • Hideaway Bay Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Hideaway Bay

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    20

    2,272 - 5,736

    1980 - 2007

    No Minimum

    No Minimum

    $725k-$7.4M

    Amenities:

    Deed Restrictions, Tennis Courts, Waterfront, Seclude Cul-De-Sac Lots.

    View Hideaway Bay Homes
  • Lands End Homes For Sale in Longboat Key, FL>

    Lands End

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    12

    2,620 - 5,060

    1966 - 2016

    3 Months

    1

    $2.5M-$10.0M

    Amenities:

    Dock, Fishing Pier, Gated Community, Maintenance Free, Tennis Courts, Water Access, Two large piers accommodate community boat slips, first come first serve.

    View Lands End Homes
Find The Right Neighborhood

Find The Right Neighborhood Fast

  • Search by price, age, and amenities
  • View matching communities on a map
  • Compare condos and neighborhoods instantly

We are local. Your information stays private.

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

You May Like:

Local Real Estate Performance Reports

Is Sarasota Single Home Market Hot, or Cold?

View latest report by location.

  • Average Price & Days on Market
  • Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
  • Inventory Supply
  • Buyer or Seller Market Indicators

Current PDF Report: (opens in new window)

Bill & Cheryl McCue - Sarasota Realtors
Bill & Cheryl McCue
Broker Associate & Realtors

(941)ย 265-0590

Buying or Selling in Bay Isles?

Your local Bay Isles real estate experts.

Bill & Cheryl McCue and the Sarasota Homes Group know Bay Isles inside and out. 23 years of experience helping buyers and sellers in this market.

  • Local Bay Isles Realtor with deep market knowledge.
  • Top 2% selling Realtor in Sarasota & Manatee County.
  • 23 years full-time experience.
  • Current listings, sold data, and market trends for this area.
  • Specializing in buying, listing, and selling homes in this market.
  • Free market valuation for owners in this area.
  • 100โ€™s of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
  • Sold over 400+ homes and counting.

Bill & Cheryl McCue

Sarasota Homes Group