Buccaneer Bay Homes For Sale | Sarasota, FL
Buccaneer Bay Community Guide
Buccaneer Bay is a community in Sarasota, built 1958-2016.
Search 900+ Neighborhoods & Condos By Name
Buccaneer Bay Real Estate in Sarasota, FL
Buccaneer Bay homes for sale sit south of Stickney Point Road, a quiet, high-demand West of Trail neighborhood near Siesta Key. Roughly 42 homes make up the community, a mix of bayfront lots with distinct water views and five private cul-de-sacs, sizes typically starting around 2,000 square feet and running well past 4,000 in the larger waterfront estates.
Boaters get sheltered, protected water with a quick, no-bridge run out to Sarasota Bay and the Gulf. Mature live oaks and lush landscaping give the streets a private, secluded feel. HOA fees stay optional and low. You’re about 3.5 miles from Siesta Key Beach, and downtown Sarasota’s arts district, hospitals, and shopping sit a short drive north.
Photos of Buccaneer Bay
Buccaneer Bay Neighborhood Facts
| Price Range: | $750k-$4.0M |
| Year Built: | 1958 – 2016 |
| Size (Sq. Ft.): | 2,135 – 5,175 |
| Min. Lease: | No Minimum |
| Leases/ Year: | No Minimum |
| Gated: | ✖ No |
| Pool: | ✖ No |
| Fences: | ✔ Yes |
| Golf Course: | ✖ No |
| CDD Fee: | ✖ No |
*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.
Amenities:
Waterfront
Fees Include:
Common grounds Maintenance
Homes For Sale in Buccaneer Bay
Honesty ยท Reputation ยท Experience ยท Top 2% Realtors in Sarasota
Map of Buccaneer Bay
Additional Buccaneer Bay Neighborhood Information
Buccaneer Bay is set high on a ridge overlooking Matheny Creek, and offers itโs lucky boat owners instant access via a dredged canal to the Bay and intracoastal waterway; easy boating is at your fingertips for a quick trip to the Gulf without any fixed bridges. The creek provides very sheltered protected water for your boat. Buyers searching for a โWest of Trailโ waterfront communities need to keep Buccaneer Bay on the short list of communities to view.
Buccaneer Bay is an ideal location is only 1.5 miles from the white sugary beaches of world famous Siesta Key Beach, which was rated as the #1 in the U.S. The community is convenient to the Downtown Arts District, Hospitals, Shopping, Banking, Eateries & I-75. Enjoy the beauty of this communityโs towering live oaks and beautiful gardens.
Buccaneer Bay Real Estate
Buccaneer Bay is about 42 homes, built between 1979 – present.
No, Buccaneer Bay does not have a community pool.
No, Buccaneer Bay is not a gated community.
The HOA maintains the common areas of the community, however homeowners are responsible for their own yard care.
No, Buccaneer Bay does not have a CDD. (CDD stands for “Community Development District”. It is an additional tax assessment included on a property’s annual real estate tax bill, which pays for the initial and ongoing infrastructure cost for community development.)
Yes, some homes in Buccaneer Bay have fencing, however there may be HOA restrictions regarding which lot locations may have a fence, or the size or type of fence allowed. It is important to check HOA rules for specific fencing requirements prior to making a purchase decision.
Buccaneer Bay is located about 7 miles from downtown Sarasota.
Buccaneer Bay is located about 3.5 miles from Siesta Key Beach.
Buccaneer Bay is located about 10.7 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.
*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.
Insight For Buccaneer Bay
Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.
Our Personal Buccaneer Bay Insights
Pros
- Really great location
- Many homes have boat docks and easy water access
- Higher grounds. Many homes donโt need flood insurance
Considerations
- Some homes need updating
Shopping
- Grocery store is 1.2 miles
- UTC Mall is 2.2 miles
- Costco is 3.5 miles
Beach
- Siesta Key Beach is 3.8 miles
- Closest beach is Crescent Beach which is 2.3 miles
Lifestyle
- Great waterfront neighborhood perfect for boaters or fishing
- Close to everything
- Casual and fine dining restaurants are close by
Downtown Sarasota
- 6.5 miles
- 14 minute drive
Explore Sarasota West of Trail Neighborhoods
Compare west of trail communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.
Filter by community features:
-
Aqualane Estates
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
109
1,834 - 4,060
1958 - 2022
No Minimum
No Minimum
$1.2M-$3.8M
Amenities:
None.
-
Avondale
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
78
1,644 - 3,906
1925 - 2023
No Minimum
No Minimum
$750k-$5.4M
Amenities:
None.
-
Ballentine Manor
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
137
1,385 - 3,906
1918 - 2024
No Minimum
No Minimum
$500k-$3.5M
Amenities:
None.
-
Bay Acres
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
97
1,760 - 4,893
1952 - 2023
1 Month
12
$400k-$5.4M
Amenities:
None.
-
Bay Point Park
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
45
2,156 - 6,429
1925 - 2014
None
None
$2.8M-$15.0M
Amenities:
No Minimum.
-
Bay View Acres
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
127
968 - 3,612
1953 - 2022
No Minimum
No Minimum
$400k-$2.7M
Amenities:
None
-
Bayside
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
40
2,115 - 2,665
2017 - 2019
1 Month
4
$900k-$3.0M
Amenities:
Gated, Maintenance-Free, Dock.
-
Bungalow Hill
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
45
1,361 - 3,591
1915 - 2024
None
None
$950k-$4.6M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Cedar Cove
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
42
1,700 - 4,065
1952 - 1993
No Minimum
No Minimum
$550k-$1.5M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Cherokee Park
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
76
2,144 - 8,125
1930 - 2019
No Minimum
No Minimum
$2.0M-$13.0M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Coral Cove
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
111
1,432 - 5,222
1954 - 2014
1 Month
12
$450k-$4.5M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Desota Park
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
127
1,524 - 5,660
1925 - 2024
1 Month
12
$970k-$3.8M
Amenities:
None
Find The Right Neighborhood Fast
We are local. Your information stays private.
We’re local. Your info stays private here.
Local Real Estate Performance Reports
Is Sarasota Single Home Market Hot, or Cold?
View latest report by location.
- Average Price & Days on Market
- Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
- Inventory Supply
- Buyer or Seller Market Indicators
Current PDF Report: (opens in new window)
Broker Associate & Realtors
Buying or Selling in Buccaneer Bay?
Your local Buccaneer Bay real estate experts.
Bill & Cheryl McCue and the Sarasota Homes Group know Buccaneer Bay inside and out. 23 years of experience helping buyers and sellers in this market.
- Local Buccaneer Bay Realtor with deep market knowledge.
- Top 2% selling Realtors in Sarasota & Manatee County.
- 23 years full-time experience.
- Current listings, sold data, and market trends for this area.
- Specializing in buying, listing, and selling homes in this market.
- Free market valuation for owners in this area.
- 100โs of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
- Sold over 500+ homes.
Bill & Cheryl McCue
Sarasota Homes Group
