Fishermens Bay Homes For Sale | Sarasota, FL
Fishermens Bay Community Guide
Fishermens Bay is a community in Sarasota, built 1989-2022.
Fishermens Bay Real Estate in Sarasota, FL
Fishermen’s Bay homes for sale sit in a small gated enclave, 17 to 20 custom waterfront estates spread across 22 acres on Sarasota’s southern end, West of the Trail. Key West style dominates here, floor plans running around 3,000 square feet, most on oversized lots up to a full acre with mature oaks and lush landscaping. No CDD applies, and homes come with deeded boat slips leading straight into the Intracoastal and out to the Gulf.
A 75 foot community pier gives residents a spot for fishing or launching a kayak, plus picnic grounds along the water. The gate sits tucked behind heavy tree cover, so the whole neighborhood feels hidden despite being minutes from Westfield Sarasota Square, Costco, and the Legacy Trail. Families have access to strong public and private schools nearby, including Pine View for gifted students.
Key Facts:
21 Residences
| Price Range: | $1.1M-$3.5M |
| Year Built: | 1989 – 2022 |
| Size (Sq. Ft.): | 3,214 – 4,158 |
| Min. Lease: | 6 Months |
| Leases/ Year: | 2 |
| Gated: | ✖ No |
| Pool: | ✖ No |
| Fences: | ✔ Yes |
| Golf Course: | ✖ No |
| CDD Fee: | ✖ No |
*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.
Amenities Includes:
75โณ Community Pier
Community Fee Includes:
Escrow Reserves Fund, Insurance, Maintenance Grounds, Private Road, Security.
Photos of Fishermens Bay
Need a different community?
Additional Fishermens Bay Neighborhood Information
Fishermens Bay is only 6 miles to Siesta Key Beach and it’s quartz-like sand, dolphins swimming through the azure waters, and tropical birds flying overhead. The public beach has volleyball courts, a shaded playground, pavilion and concession stand. Siesta Key hosts the yearly sand sculpting competitions and collegiate volleyball tournaments. Siesta Village has a variety of shops, ice cream parlor, seafood restaurants, beach bars and live entertainment.
Downtown Sarasota has an amazing display of art galleries, museums, performing arts, international restaurants, and theatrical venues . Residents of Fishermens Bay can take a quick drive over the Ringling Causeway to St. Armandโs Circle, an inviting area for unique shopping and restaurants with international cuisine. Lido Beach is also a popular destination in the area.
Fishermens Bay Real Estate
Fishermens Bay is about 21 homes, built in the 1980’s-1990’s.
No, Fishermens Bay does not have a community pool.
Yes, Fishermens Bay is a gated community.
The HOA maintains the common areas of the community, however homeowners are responsible for their own yard care.
No, Fishermens Bay does not have a CDD. (CDD stands for “Community Development District”. It is an additional tax assessment included on a property’s annual real estate tax bill, which pays for the initial and ongoing infrastructure cost for community development.)
Yes, some homes in Fishermens Bay have fencing, however there may be HOA restrictions regarding which lot locations may have a fence, or the size or type of fence allowed. It is important to check HOA rules for specific fencing requirements prior to making a purchase decision.
Fishermens Bay is located about 9.5 miles from downtown Sarasota.
Fishermens Bay is located about 6 miles from Siesta Key Beach.
Fishermens Bay is located about 13.5 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.
*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.
Insight For Fishermens Bay
Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.
Our Personal Fishermens Bay Insights
Pros
- A bit less traffic in this area of Sarasota
- Gated community for increased security
- Community dock slips available on first come first serve basis
Honesty ยท Reputation ยท Experience ยท Top 2% Sales Team in Sarasota
Homes For Sale in Fishermens Bay
Need a Fishermens Bay real estate agent?
Bill & Cheryl McCue and their team at Sarasota Homes Group are a top 2% selling team in Sarasota and Manatee County.
- 23 years full-time experience
- Specialize in buyer, selling, and market valuation for Fishermens Bay home owners.
- 100โs of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
- Sold over 400+ homes to date.
Bill & Cheryl McCue & team
Sarasota Waterfront Neighborhoods Index
Quick summary of each neighborhood
Local Real Estate Performance Reports
(Updated Weekly)
Is Sarasota Single Home Market Hot, or Cold?
View latest report by location.
- Average Price & Days on Market
- Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
- Inventory Supply
- Buyer or Seller Market Indicators
