Hartsdale Homes For Sale | Sarasota, FL

Hartsdale Community Guide

Hartsdale is a community in Sarasota, built 1923-2024.

Hartsdale Real Estate in Sarasota, FL

Hartsdale homes for sale sit West of the Trail in central Sarasota, originally developed back in 1937, with older homes steadily being replaced by luxury single-family construction. Updated smaller homes start around 1,700 square feet, while newer builds run up to 4,300 square feet and beyond, giving the neighborhood real range across architectural styles and price points.

Tree-lined streets, lush landscaping, and sidewalks give Hartsdale a small-village feel, and top-rated Sarasota schools sit just a few blocks away. No HOA restricts the neighborhood, so no monthly fee either. Southside Village’s shops and restaurants are within walking distance, and Sarasota Memorial Hospital sits close by too.

Key Facts:

50 Residences

Price Range:	$900k-$4.2M
Year Built:	1923 – 2024
Size (Sq. Ft.):	1,879 – 3,970
Min. Lease:	No Minimum
Leases/ Year:	No Minimum

Gated:	✖ No
Pool:	✖ No
Fences:	✔ Yes
Golf Course:	✖ No
CDD Fee:	✖ No

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Amenities Includes:

None

Community Fee Includes:

None

Photos of Hartsdale

Need a different community?

Alternative Communities List Neighborhood Finder Tool

Additional Hartsdale Neighborhood Information

Hartsdale is located about a mile south of downtown Sarasota, in the charming and historic area of Southside Village. There visitors and residents will find a gourmet market, trendy shops, playground and neighborhood parks. It’s an easy stroll to the coffee shop, or to dine at one of the many restaurants located in and around the village. The Sarasota Memorial hospital and medical offices are in close proximity of the Hartsdale neighborhood too.

Hartsdale Frequently Asked Questions

Hartsdale Real Estate

How large is the Hartsdale neighborhood in Sarasota?

Hartsdale is about 50 homes, built between 1937 – present.

Is there a community pool in Hartsdale?

No, Hartsdale does not have a community pool.

Is Hartsdale in Sarasota a gated community?

No, Hartsdale is not a gated community.

Is Hartsdale in Sarasota a maintenance-free neighborhood?

The HOA maintains the common areas of the community, however homeowners are responsible for their own yard care.

Does Hartsdale in Sarasota have a CDD?

No, Hartsdale does not have a CDD. (CDD stands for “Community Development District”. It is an additional tax assessment included on a property’s annual real estate tax bill, which pays for the initial and ongoing infrastructure cost for community development.)

Does Hartsdale allow fences?

Yes, some homes in Hartsdale have fencing, however there may be city restrictions regarding which lot locations may have a fence, or the size or type of fence allowed. It is important to check city rules for specific fencing requirements prior to making a purchase decision.

How far is Hartsdale from downtown Sarasota?

Hartsdale is located about 2 miles from downtown Sarasota.

What public beach is closest to Hartsdale?

Hartsdale is located about 5.5 miles from Holmes Beach.

How far is the Sarasota International Airport from Hartsdale?

Hartsdale is located about 6 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Insight For Hartsdale

Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.

Hartsdale Homes For Sale in Sarasota, FL.

Our Personal Hartsdale Insights

Pros

Convenient location
Very close to Sarasota memorial hospital
Walkable to Southside Elementary School

Considerations

Some homes are older and may need updating

Shopping

Grocery store is 1.3 miles
UTC Mall is 10.7 miles
Costco is 6.4 miles

Beach

Siesta Key Beach is 5.1 miles
Closest beach is Siesta Key

Lifestyle

Great neighborhood close to Southside Village
Very nice tree-lines streets
Walkable to restaurants

Downtown Sarasota

1.8 miles
6 minute drive

Honesty · Reputation · Experience · Top 2% Sales Team in Sarasota

Sarasota Homes Group The Best Sarasota Realtors

Sell With Us & Save About Our Team

Receive New Listing Alerts

Homes For Sale in Hartsdale

Bill and Cheryl McCue - Sarasota's Best Realtors — Bill McCue, Broker Associate

Need a Hartsdale real estate agent?

Bill & Cheryl McCue and their talented team are a top 2% selling team in Sarasota and Manatee County.

23 years full-time experience.
Specializing in assisting buyers, listing & selling.
Market valuations for Hartsdale owners.
100’s of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
Sold over 400+ homes and counting.

Bill & Cheryl McCue

Sarasota Homes Group

Sarasota FL. Neighborhoods Index

Quick summary of each neighborhood

View Index

Explore Featured Sarasota Neighborhoods

Compare our featured communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.

More Details

Filter by community features:

1-12 of 133 Filtered Results

Amberlea

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

112

2,536 - 3,076

1980 - 2022

1 Month

6

$600k-$810k

Amenities:

Gated Community, Well-maintained landscaping, 5 Lakes, Low HOA fees.

Learn More
Aqualane Estates

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

109

1,834 - 4,060

1958 - 2022

No Minimum

No Minimum

$1.2M-$3.8M

Amenities:

None.

Learn More
Arbor Lakes

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

400

2,055 - 5,900

2015 - 2020

1 Month

4

$600k-$1.3M

Amenities:

Heated pool, spa, children waterpark, playground, volleyball court, basketball court, firepit, BBQ area, Covered Pavilion, dog park.

Learn More
Arbor Lakes

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

100

1,696 - 2,884

2015 - 2022

3 Months

2

$400k-$900k

Amenities:

Community Recreational Center on the Braden River with a Jr. Olympic pool, nature trail, private sitting dock and canoe/kayak launch along the river.

Learn More
Artistry

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

450

1,758 - 4,163

2017 - 2023

12 Months

1

$650k-$1.4M

Amenities:

Gated, heated pool, fitness center, playground, basketball, tennis courts, pickleball courts

Learn More
Ashton Cove

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

19

N/A

2017 - 2018

6 Months

2

Amenities:

Low HOA fees.

Learn More
Ashton Oaks

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

20

N/A

2015 - 2018

3 Months

2

Amenities:

None.

Learn More
Ashton Palms

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

32

N/A

2015 - 2017

7 Months

2

Amenities:

Gated.

Learn More
Avondale

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

78

1,644 - 3,906

1925 - 2023

No Minimum

No Minimum

$750k-$5.4M

Amenities:

None.

Learn More
Ballentine Manor

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

137

1,385 - 3,906

1918 - 2024

No Minimum

No Minimum

$500k-$3.5M

Amenities:

None.

Learn More
Bay Acres

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

97

1,760 - 4,893

1952 - 2023

1 Month

12

$400k-$5.4M

Amenities:

None.

Learn More
Bay Landing

Total Homes:

Size (SqFt.):

Year Built:

Min. Lease:

Leases/ Yr:

Pricing:

132

2,051 - 3,377

2019 - 2022

8-12 Months

1

$400k-$700k

Amenities:

Club House, Dog Park, Fitness Center, Pool, Tot Lot, All-Concrete Block Construction.

Learn More