/ Casey Key Condos

Casey Key Condos For Sale

Casey Key FL. Condominiums

Although Casey Key is a more of a private secluded barrier island featuring large luxury estate homes, Casey Key condos for sale are located towards the south end on Casey Key. If you are interested in beach condos, there will be more condos available in Lido Key, Longboat Key and Siesta Key.

Quick Actions:

Listing Alerts Community List Buyers Guide Sell & Save Contact

SArasota Market REcap of 2025

Did The Sarasota Market TANK in 2025?

What the 2025 Sarasota market means if you’re buying in 2026.

Sarasota Homes Group The Best Sarasota Realtors

Current Condos For Sale in Casey Key

Search MLS

Condos For Sale in Downtown Sarasota, FL.

Casey Key Condos

New Listing Alerts

The best condos sell fast.
Receive new listing alerts.
Promptly sent to your email.

send new Listings

Unlike National Websites, We Don’t Sell Your Info.

Photos of Casey Key, FL.

Insight For The Casey Key Community

Casey Key Condos For Sale - Exterior Building & Waterfront

Pros

More private and exclusive area

Considerations

Very few condos are available in the area

Shopping

Several grocery stores within 1-2 miles
UTC Mall is about 20.2 miles
Ellenton Outlet Mall is 16.7 miles

Beach

Casey Key offers it’s own private beach access, along with Nokomis Public Beach Access
Siesta Key Beach is 12.4 miles or 28 minute drive

Lifestyle

Great private beach neighborhood
Private beach and less crowds
Restaurants within minutes

Downtown

15.1 miles
32 minute drive

Additional Casey Key Condo Information

One of the very few Casey Key Condos is the Beach Retreat on Casey Key. Nothing else like this condo can be found on the Key. This free-standing condominium offers direct Gulf of Mexico ocean views. Owners at this condo enjoy deeded beach access, as well as open dock privileges for six slips on the canal! The condo unit could make a great investment for real estate investors due to the abundance of rental opportunities here. There is no limit on rentals, with the option of independently renting or utilizing rental management team from the neighboring resort.

Casey Key Condos Frequently Asked Questions

Casey Key Condo Real Estate

How big is Casey Key?

Casey Key is a private and serene barrier island spanning 8 miles.

Is Casey Key located near downtown Sarasota?

Casey Key sits just south of the well-known island of Siesta Key, positioned between Sarasota and Venice, FL. A trip to downtown Sarasota would take you approximately 30 minutes.

Are there condos on Casey Key?

The Beach Retreat on Casey Key is one of the only options. However, this condo boasts beautiful views, a peaceful setting and very few rental restrictions. There are also a few motels located towards the southern end of the island.

Are the beaches of Casey Key private or public beaches?

Casey Key is one of the more exclusive islands in Sarasota, while there are almost no condos the homes are considered beach estate homes and beach rental properties with exclusive private beach access. There are two small public access points on the island these are Nokomis Beach and the Jetty Park area. The beach sand is considered more brown color and has a higher shell content compared to the white powder of Siesta Key.

Does Casey Key area bring many tourists?

While Siesta Key Beach is the more popular beach for those vacationing, people who visit Casey Key are usually locals from the surrounding area. The island of Casey Key is known for its exclusivity and privacy.

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.