Sarasota, FL. Homes For Sale

Home » Casey Key Homes For Sale
Casey Key real estate for sale in Nokomis, FL.
Casey Key homes in Sarasota Area

Casey Key Homes Overview

Location:
Rt. 41 to West on Blackburn Road, Nokomis, FL. 34275
# of Neighborhoods:
1
Related Links:

Casey Key Real Estate in Sarasota, FL.

When clients contact us and indicate they are looking for a luxury residence with “privacy” as a top must-have, we turn our search to Casey Key real estate first!  Residents of Casey Key enjoy 8 miles of the most scenic and grand luxury homes in Sarasota!  The meandering curvy single lane road winds down through the barrier island, delivering just glimpses of each estate.  There are several famous names who have chosen Casey Key as their home away from home on the Gulf Coast of FL. It’s a peaceful and gorgeous barrier island located to the south of the more touristy Siesta Key barrier island. Read more

Current Homes For Sale in Casey Key

Price
Beds
Baths
2905 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
New Listing - 4 days online
1 / 13
$5,995,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
5
BED
7
TOTAL BATHS
5,335
SQFT
2905 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
412 S Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
New Listing - a week online
1 / 50
$3,950,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
6
BED
5
TOTAL BATHS
3,983
SQFT
412 S Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
GEDNEY RICHARD H INC Subdivision
602 S Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
New Listing - a week online
1 / 50
$6,395,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
6
TOTAL BATHS
6,472
SQFT
602 S Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
GEDNEY RICHARD H INC Subdivision
140 N Casey Key Road Osprey FL 34229
1 / 34
$2,495,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
4
TOTAL BATHS
2,773
SQFT
140 N Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
ACREAGE & UNREC Subdivision
3704 Sandspur Lane Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 77
$899,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
2
TOTAL BATHS
2,258
SQFT
3704 Sandspur Lane
Nokomis, FL 34275
ACREAGE & UNREC Subdivision
4028 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 56
$759,900
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,676
SQFT
4028 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
1588 N Casey Key Road Osprey FL 34229
1 / 50
$10,500,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
6
BED
8
TOTAL BATHS
7,760
SQFT
1588 N Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
PALMER Subdivision
316 N Casey Key Road Osprey FL 34229
1 / 76
$8,484,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
6
BED
9
TOTAL BATHS
7,121
SQFT
316 N Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
CASEY KEY Subdivision
508 S Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 45
$2,499,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
4
TOTAL BATHS
2,342
SQFT
508 S Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
12 N Casey Key Road Osprey FL 34229
1 / 20
$1,200,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
2
BED
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,657
SQFT
12 N Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
CASEY KEY Subdivision
1010 Gulf Winds Way Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 50
$1,449,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
5
TOTAL BATHS
3,581
SQFT
1010 Gulf Winds Way
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY ESTATES, Subdivision
407 S Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 44
$899,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
2
BED
2
TOTAL BATHS
1,482
SQFT
407 S Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
1027 N Casey Key Road Osprey FL 34229
1 / 32
$2,695,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,990
SQFT
1027 N Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
CASEY KEY Subdivision
3250 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 21
$2,950,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
4
TOTAL BATHS
4,640
SQFT
3250 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
2712 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 35
$1,895,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
2
TOTAL BATHS
2,365
SQFT
2712 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
1906 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
Price Change - 3 weeks ago
1 / 47
$4,995,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
6
TOTAL BATHS
6,767
SQFT
1906 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
2816 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 50
$1,900,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
2
TOTAL BATHS
1,767
SQFT
2816 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
CASEY KEY Subdivision
814 N Casey Key Road Osprey FL 34229
1 / 50
$7,900,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
6
TOTAL BATHS
6,552
SQFT
814 N Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
CASEY KEY Subdivision
3516 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 43
$2,450,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
3
BED
3
TOTAL BATHS
3,414
SQFT
3516 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
GRAHAMS POINT Subdivision
1140 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275
1 / 50
$1,480,000
Single Family Home For Sale
Active
4
BED
4
TOTAL BATHS
4,264
SQFT
1140 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
1933- SEAGRAPE POINT Subdivision

Insight For The Island Of Casey Key

Casey Key Condos For Sale - Exterior Building & Waterfront
Pros:
  • Quiet and more private area
  • Private beach access for most homes
  • Gulf to bay expansive lots available
Considerations:
  • A bit further away from the attractions of central Sarasota
Shopping:
  • Grocery store is about 3.5 miles
  • UTC Mall is 22.7 miles
Lifestyle:
  • A more private and exclusive feel than Siesta Key, Lido Key, or Longboat Key
  • Luxury homes and estates with some celebrities living on Casey Key
Beach:
  • Nokomis Beach is about 1 miles south
  • 25 minute drive to Siesta Key
Downtown Sarasota:
  • 15.1 miles
  • 32 minute drive

Additional Casey Key Community Information

Calming waters surround Casey Key homes, with some select residences spanning the entire width of the island, thus delivering the highly-coveted “Gulf to Bay” views only Casey Key can provide.  With only a total of approximately 400 luxury homes, you can be assured Casey Key is exclusive and private.  We feel Casey Key real estate is the perfect fit for residence who want to enjoy peace, quiet, serenity, but also live in closer proximity to downtown Sarasota, and all the culture and arts that accompanies that.

Sarasota Luxury Home Neighborhoods

Contact Us | Ask A Question

Bill McCue & John Brink - Sarasota Realtors Testimonial
Bill McCue & John Brink – Broker Associates, The We Sell Sarasota Team
  • Local market stats and great deals insight.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Technology is great, but it’s nice to speak with a live person!
Bill McCue & John Brink
(941) 404-5795

Bill took care of my needs from start to finish. I was in need of a fast closing , Bill and his wife came through for me. They stay in touch making sure things are going ok. I would use their services again.

Bill helped us sell a condo for a family friend. Bill was very thorough with every detail from pricing to the closing. Bill walks you through every step making sure you understand the whole process of selling a home. I would recommend Bill to anyone selling a home. Thanks for your help.

Our decision to partner with Bill McCue will be the best decision you make when purchasing a new home. My husband and I first met Bill when we contacted him to show us a town house. From the moment we met him we saw in him an agent who was friendly, down to earth, and very professional. He knows his stuff! Bill made that happen by selling our home in a week and negotiating another townhouse – unbelievable! Through every step, Bill was on top of everything.

Bill is the consummate professional. He took care of every detail of the listing for us, worked with the buyers and their agent to negotiate a fair price, and managed the necessary logistics easily. Highly recommend Bill and his team.

We now consider Bill and Cheryl a friend and would highly recommend them to anyone that is searching for a home. Thanks again Bill McCue and Cheryl McCue for being such a pleasure to work with. We just can’t thank you enough!

Bill was very professional and knowledgeable assisting me through the entire home buying process. His assistance made a very stressful situation more manageable.

We met Bill McCue by a happy accident. He responded to an inquiry we made on a house in Sarasota. He was not even working for us (yet), but he impressed us with both his knowledge and his caring, and eventually hired him as our Realtor. We felt totally safe in negotiating the final purchase, because we knew Bill would make sure we were getting a house that was safe and would have no surprises. We’re really glad we met Bill, and we’re definitely going to ask him to help sell our previous house once we’ve completed a few maintenance repairs.

Bill, you hooked me up with a great investment that I know I will make good money on in the future. I referred two other people to you to that are happy with your fast follow-up and market expertise. Keep up the good work!

Bill, I thought we were giving you a challenge no Realtor could meet. We were looking for a very particular type of property and you found us the perfect match. Great work, you actually listened to us! That is hard to find now-a-days. Then, we listed our current home with you, and you sold it fast for a price we were happy with. Thank you so much for all your help with everything!

Bill, It was a pleasure to deal with you. I wouldn’t hesitate to use your services again the next time I need to buy or sell.

Thank you for selling our Condo in record time for a price HIGHER than our asking price. Your plan was excellent, and you did what you said you would do. I have heard of other people who had nightmares selling their homes with other agents, but your service was flawless. Thank you very much!

Bill, I have never worked with an agent who cares so much and works so hard for his clients. You worked for over a year to find and get us what we were looking for. You never lost your sense of humor and helped us through some very frustrating situations. We will always consider you our friend rather than our agent.