Banyan Bay Club Condos For Sale | Longboat Key, FL

Banyan Bay Club Community Guide

Banyan Bay Club is a condominium community in Longboat Key, built 1973-1974 with a community pool.

Banyan Bay Club Condominiums in Longboat Key, FL.

Banyan Bay Club condos for sale sit on Longboat Key, an 11-mile barrier island that offers some of the most sought-after real estate on Florida’s Gulf Coast. The community is small and intentional, with just 44 units at 5260 Gulf of Mexico Drive. Depending on which unit you choose, you are looking out over either the Gulf or the Bay, and both orientations deliver the kind of water views that make Longboat Key living worth it. Units run two to three bedrooms and average between 1,200 and 1,400 square feet, built in 1974 with a scale and character that larger resort-style complexes cannot replicate.

The amenities here cover every angle of coastal living. A heated pool, fitness center, tennis courts, clubhouse, and barbecue area handle the day-to-day. A fishing pier, kayak launch, and small boat dock put the water within arm’s reach, and dedicated beach access with lounge chairs means sunset watching is as easy as walking out your door. Beach equipment storage and assigned covered parking add the kind of practical details that make a real difference for full-time residents and seasonal owners alike. Banyan Bay Club is also pet-friendly for condo owners, rounding out a community that is as livable as it is beautiful.

Key Facts:

44 Residences

Price Range:$595kโ€“$794k
Year Built:1973 – 1974
Size (Sq. Ft.):1,1128 – 1,460
Min. Lease:3 Months
Leases/ Year:3
Gated:✖ No
Pool:✔ Yes
Pets Allowed:✔ Yes
Golf Course: ✖ No
CDD Fee:✖ No

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Amenities Includes:

Dock, Fishing Pier, Fitness, Irrigation, Maintenance Free, Recreation Building, Tennis Courts, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

Community Fee Includes:

Building Exterior, Community Pool, Flood Insurance, Ground Maintenance, Insurance Building, Manager, Tennis Courts, Trash Removal, Water/Sewer.

Additional Banyan Bay Club Condo Information

Banyan Bay Club is within walking distance for luncheons and casual dining. There are several outdoor cafes, ice cream parlors and coffee shops. You can spend an afternoon at the Centre Shops of Longboat Key, a quaint shopping mall featuring clothing and beachwear, antiques, art galleries and more. Publix grocery super market and convenience stores are close by. The Mote Marine Laboratory, an educational facility is popular among family and friends. This condo community is waterfront, so it is located in a flood zone.

Downtown Sarasota has that village feel with shops, gourmet restaurants, boutiques, parks, marina, galleries and museums. St. Armandโ€™s Circle is a fun destination filled with stores, restaurants that was built around a park with Italian statuary. Banyan Bay Club is beachside making this stretch of Longboat Key perfect for retirees, a vacation spot or for an investment.

Banyan Bay Club Frequently Asked Questions

Banyan Bay Club Condominiums


How large is the Banyan Bay Club condo community in Longboat Key?

Banyan Bay Club has about 44 condos, built in 1975.

Is there a pool in Banyan Bay Club?

Yes, Banyan Bay Club has a heated pool.

Is Banyan Bay Club in Longboat Key a gated community?

No, Banyan Bay Club is not a gated community.

Is Banyan Bay Club in Longboat Key located in a golf community?

No, Banyan Bay Club is not located in a golf course community, but you may join the Longboat Key Club which offers the Islandside 18 Hole Golf Course and Harbourside 27 Hole Golf Course. Additionally, there are two clubhouses, 6 restaurants, an award winning tennis center with 22 Har-Tru courts, fitness center, full-service spa, and a 29 slip marina within Longboat Key Club.

How far is Banyan Bay Club from downtown Sarasota?

Banyan Bay Club is located about 10.9 miles from downtown Sarasota.

What public beach is closest to Banyan Bay Club?

Banyan Bay Club is located about 1.8 miles from Longboat Key Public Beach.

How far is the Sarasota International Airport from Banyan Bay Club?

Banyan Bay Club is located about 14.2 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.

Are pets allowed in Banyan Bay Club?

Yes, however we recommend that you consult with a Realtor to get specific pet policy info for this community. We are happy to help you.

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Insight For Banyan Bay Club

Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.

Banyan Bay Club Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.
Sarasota Homes Group Logo

Our Personal Banyan Bay Club Insights

Sarasota FL. Homes For Sale
"Pros" icon - Happy Face

Pros

  • Private beach
  • Nice selection of amenities
  • Fishing dock and Kayak storage
traffic jam
"Cons" icon - Indifferent Face

Considerations

  • Building was built in 1975
shopping district near UTC Mall
"Shopping" icon - Shopping Bag

Shopping

  • Publix is located 3.6 miles away
  • UTC Mall is 20 Milesย  (45-50 minutes)
  • Saint Armands Circle boutique shopping is 8.3 Miles (14 minutes)
Siesta Key Beach Residences Condos in Siesta Key, FL. - Beach
"Beach" icon - Beach and umbrella

Beach

  • Longboat Key is private beach
  • Lido Key Beach is 8.9 miles
  • Siesta Key Beach is 17.9 miles
Couple Outdoor Dining
"Lifestyle" icon - Fork & Knife

Lifestyle

  • Peaceful private beach living
  • First-class amenities optionally available at Longboat Key Club
  • Fine and casual restaurants located on Longboat Key
One Park Condos in Downtown Sarasota, FL - Exterior of Building at Sunset
"Downtown" icon - Downtown buildings

Downtown Sarasota

  • 12.5 miles
  • 25 minute drive

Honesty ยท Reputation ยท Experience ยท Top 2% Sales Team in Sarasota

Sarasota Homes Group The Best Sarasota Realtors

Condos For Sale in Banyan Bay Club | Longboat Key, FL.

GET INSTANT

New Listing Alerts

Banyan Bay Club

  • The best condos move fast
  • Instant email alerts
  • Never miss a new listing

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

Bill and Cheryl McCue - Sarasota's Best Realtors
Bill McCue, Broker Associate

Need a Banyan Bay Club real estate agent?

Bill & Cheryl McCue and their talented team are a top 2% selling team in Sarasota and Manatee County.

  • 23 years full-time experience.
  • Specializing in assisting buyers, listing & selling.
  • Market valuations for Banyan Bay Club owners.
  • 100โ€™s of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
  • Sold over 400+ homes and counting.

Bill & Cheryl McCue

Sarasota Homes Group

Longboat Key Neighborhoods Index

Quick summary of each neighborhood

View Index

Explore Longboat Key FL. Condominiums

Compare Longboat Key condo communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.

More Details

Filter by community features:

1-12 of 61 Filtered Results
  • Aquarius Club Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Aquarius Club

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    57

    1,551

    1974 - 1975

    3 Months

    1

    $1.5Mโ€“$1.6M

    Amenities:

    Fitness, Laundry Facility, Recreation Building, Tennis Courts, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
  • Bay Harbour Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Bay Harbour

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    39

    1,194 - 1,474

    1969 - 1970

    1 Month

    2

    $650kโ€“$700k

    Amenities:

    Boat Slips, Dock, Elevators, Fitness, Maintenance Free, Storage, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
  • Bayport Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Bayport

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    136

    1,456 - 2,186

    1980 - 1985

    1 Month

    12

    $450kโ€“$1.4M

    Amenities:

    Building Exterior, Cable, Community Pool, Escrow Reserves Fund, Flood Insurance, Ground Maintenance, Insurance Building, Manager, Pest Control, Recreational Facilities, Roof, Tennis Courts, Trash Removal, Water/Sewer.

    Learn More
  • Beach Castle Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Beach Castle

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    21

    711 - 2,330

    1972 - 1976

    1-7 Days

    365

    $450k-$845k

    Amenities:

    Community Hot Tub/Spa, Fishing Pier, Laundry Facility, Maintenance Free, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
  • Beach Harbor Club Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Beach Harbor Club

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    133

    698 - 2,544

    1969 - 1970

    3 Months

    2

    $290kโ€“$550k

    Amenities:

    Boat Slip, Buyer Approval Required, Dock, Elevators, Fishing Pier, Fitness, Recreation Building, Storage, Shuffleboard, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
  • Beaches Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Beaches

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    73

    1,510 - 2,122

    1983 - 1984

    3 Months

    2

    $1.0Mโ€“$2.5M

    Amenities:

    On-Site manager, Gated Community, 24 hr Concierge, Beach Front Views, Elevators, Fitness Facility, Gated, Media Room, Pool, Spa, Tennis.

    Learn More
  • Beachplace Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Beachplace

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    336

    1,172 - 1,819

    1979 - 1981

    1 Month

    12

    $600kโ€“$2.2M

    Amenities:

    Recreation Building, Elevators, Fitness Facility, Pool, Tennis Courts, Gated Community.

    Learn More
  • Buttonwood Cove Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Buttonwood Cove

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    56

    1,284 - 2,568

    1979 - 1980

    1 Month

    3

    $440kโ€“$1.0M

    Amenities:

    Dock, Elevators, Fishing Pier, Maintenance Free, Recreation Building, Storage, Tennis Courts, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
  • Cabana Beach Club Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Cabana Beach Club

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    11

    612 - 990

    1970 - 1971

    1-7 Days

    52

    $400k-$500k

    Amenities:

    BBQ picnic area, Beach Access, Private Boat Docks, Laundry Facility, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
  • Casa Del Mar Condos in Longboat Key, FL. - Building

    Casa Del Mar

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    89

    900 - 1,000

    1972 - 1973

    1-7 Days

    52

    $600kโ€“$800k

    Amenities:

    Pool, Tennis Courts, Pickleball, Basketball, Shuffleboard, Kayak Racks, Fitness Room, Clubhouse, Library, Storage.

    Learn More
  • Castillian Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Castillian

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    60

    1,340 - 1,870

    1978 - 1979

    1 Month

    2

    $900k-$1.25M

    Amenities:

    Heated oversized pool, Spa, Tennis Court, Secured Entry, Under-Building Parking, Storage locker.

    Learn More
  • Cedars East Condos For Sale in Longboat Key, FL.

    Cedars East

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    94

    1,332 - 2,880

    1988 - 1991

    2 Weeks

    26

    $900kโ€“$1.5M

    Amenities:

    Fishing Pier, Fitness, No Truck/RV/Motorcycle Parking, Not all amenities included in HOA Fees, Recreation Building, Special Community Restrictions, Tennis Courts, Water Access, Waterfront Complex.

    Learn More
Find The Right CONDO Community

Find The Right Condo Community Fast

  • Search by price, age, and amenities
  • View matching communities on a map
  • Compare Sarasota condo buildings instantly

We are local. Your information stays private.

You May Like:

Local Real Estate Performance Reports

Is Sarasota Condo Market Hot, or Cold?

View latest report by location.

  • Average Price & Days on Market
  • Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
  • Inventory Supply
  • Buyer or Seller Market Indicators

Current PDF Report: (opens in new window)