Bay Island Shores Homes For Sale | Siesta Key, FL
Bay Island Shores Community Guide
Bay Island Shores is a community in Siesta Key, built 1952-2015.
Search 900+ Neighborhoods & Condos By Name
Bay Island Shores Real Estate in Siesta Key, FL
Bay Island Shores homes for sale sit within a luxury waterfront community on the northeastern tip of Siesta Key, roughly 166 homes built anywhere from 1925 to present. Deep sailboat water and quick access to Sarasota Bay, Big Pass, and the Gulf of Mexico make this one of the top spots on the island for serious boaters.
No gate, no formal HOA fee for most single family homes, though some condo subareas run around $300 a month. Prices here typically start around $2.5 million and climb well past $5 million for the finest waterfront estates. You’re less than a mile from public beach access, about 2 miles from Siesta Village, and roughly 9 minutes from downtown Sarasota.
Photos of Bay Island Shores
Bay Island Shores Neighborhood Facts
| Price Range: | $2.4M-$7.0M |
| Year Built: | 1952 – 2015 |
| Size (Sq. Ft.): | 2,943 – 6,827 |
| Min. Lease: | 1 Week |
| Leases/ Year: | 52 |
| Gated: | ✖ No |
| Pool: | ✖ No |
| Fences: | ✖ No |
| Golf Course: | ✖ No |
| CDD Fee: | ✖ No |
*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.
Amenities:
Waterfront.
Fees Include:
No HOA.
Homes For Sale in Bay Island Shores
Honesty ยท Reputation ยท Experience ยท Top 2% Sales Team in Sarasota
Map of Bay Island Shores
Additional Bay Island Shores Neighborhood Information
The Bay Island Shores community is known for its luxurious homes that redefine island living. Many of the homes in this neighborhood are waterfront homes with views of or access to Sarasota Bay or Roberts Bay. In 2022, the median real estate price in Bay Island/Siesta Key is about $2.8 million dollars. The Bay Island Shores community is highly sought after by luxury home buyers who are looking for that premium waterfront lifestyle and easy access to all the culture and arts of Sarasota.
Bay Island SHoRes Real Estate
Bay Island Shores is about 166 homes, built between 1925-2022+.
No, Bay Island Shores does not have a community pool.
No, Bay Island Shores is not a gated community.
The homeowners are responsible for their own yard care.
Yes, some homes in Bay Island Shores have fencing, however there may be city restrictions regarding which lot locations may have a fence, or the size or type of fence allowed. It is important to check rules for specific fencing requirements prior to making a purchase decision.
Bay Island Shores is located about 0.5 miles from beach access point # 1 located at 3940 N. Shell Road.
Bay Island Shores is located about 3.5 miles from downtown Sarasota.
Bay Island Shores is located about 7.5 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.
*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.
Insight For Bay Island Shores
Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.
Our Personal Bay Island Shores Insights
Lifestyle
- Great waterfront neighborhood in a fabulous location
- Beach vacation vibe
- Both fine dining and casual beach bars within minutes
Explore Siesta Key FL. Neighborhoods
Compare Siesta Key communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.
Filter by community features:
-
Banyan Club
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
13
N/A
1979 - 1982
8-12 Months
1
Amenities:
Pool, Tennis Court, Maintenance-Free Landscaping.
-
Bay Island
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
166
1,500 - 8,138
1925 - 2024
1 Week
52
$1.0M-$18.0M
Amenities:
Waterfront.
-
Bayou Louise
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
25
N/A
1940 - 1988
1 Week
52
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Blind Pass
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
12
2,256 - 15,000
1954 - 2010
1 Week
52
$1.3M-$8.5M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Cocoanut Bayou
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
50
3,147 - 6,838
1950 - 2012
No Minimum
52
$3.0M-$10.0M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Fiddler Bayou
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
11
1,700 - 8,600
1950 - 2008
No Minimum
No Minimum
$400k-$15.0M
Amenities:
No HOA
-
Gulf Water View
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
250
1,869 - 7,052
1950 - 2024
Varies
Varies
$500k-$3.0M
Amenities:
No HOA in most neighborhoods
-
Harmony
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
96
1,930 - 5,078
1955 - 2024
1 Month
12
$995k-$4.5M
Amenities:
No HOA
-
Hidden Harbor
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
45
1,358 - 8,165
1954 - 2024
1 Month
12
$1.6M-$15.0M
Amenities:
Waterfront, Deed Restrictions, Homes with Boat Docks.
-
Mangroves
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
27
2,567 - 3,917
1975 - 1989
8-12 Months
1
$1.1M-$3.5M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Midnight Harbor
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
13
2,522 - 5,142
1951 - 2006
No Minimum
No Minimum
$1.9M-$4.5M
Amenities:
Waterfront
-
Mira Mar Beach
Total Homes:
Size (SqFt.):
Year Built:
Min. Lease:
Leases/ Yr:
Pricing:
104
1,526 - 4,380
1925 - 2023
1-7 Days
365
$2.5M-$5.5M
Amenities:
None
Find The Right Neighborhood Fast
We are local. Your information stays private.
We’re local. Your info stays private here.
Local Real Estate Performance Reports
Is Sarasota Single Home Market Hot, or Cold?
View latest report by location.
- Average Price & Days on Market
- Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
- Inventory Supply
- Buyer or Seller Market Indicators
Current PDF Report: (opens in new window)
Broker Associate & Realtors
Buying or Selling in Bay Island Shores?
Your local Bay Island Shores real estate experts.
Bill & Cheryl McCue and the Sarasota Homes Group know Bay Island Shores inside and out. 23 years of experience helping buyers and sellers in this market.
- Local Bay Island Shores Realtor with deep market knowledge.
- Top 2% selling Realtor in Sarasota & Manatee County.
- 23 years full-time experience.
- Current listings, sold data, and market trends for this area.
- Specializing in buying, listing, and selling homes in this market.
- Free market valuation for owners in this area.
- 100โs of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
- Sold over 400+ homes and counting.
Bill & Cheryl McCue
Sarasota Homes Group
