Siesta Key Homes For Sale

/ Siesta Key Homes

Siesta Key Homes Community Guide

Siesta Key Homes offers properties near world-famous beaches with strong rental appeal, attracting buyers seeking lifestyle and investment.

Siesta Key Real Estate in Sarasota, FL.

Siesta Key homes for sale line an 8 mile barrier island known for its large public beach and an active, sun-worshiping crowd. The area between the north and south bridges runs the most touristy, which makes it a strong pick for investors chasing daily, weekly, or monthly rental income.

Most waterfront homes here sit on deep water canals rather than directly on the Gulf; true beachfront single family homes are rare and priced accordingly. Year-round residents mix with vacation home owners throughout the island. Rental rules vary hard by zoning district, so confirm short-term rental eligibility before you buy if income matters to your decision.

Quick Search:


Additional Siesta Key Neighborhood Information

There are two main access roads to access the island, referred to as the north bridge and south bridge. Siesta Drive connects to the very north section of Siesta Key with a draw bridge, while the Stickney Point Road south bridge connects to the island about 4 miles to the south via a drawbridge. Stickney Point Drive leads beach-goers and residents onto the island which leads to a “T”. Making a left and heading south on the island leads to a quieter Siesta Key experience with less traffic, while a right turn navigates straight into the main public beach area and Siesta Village.

The Popularity of Siesta Key

The heart of the island is positioned between the two bridges, but there are many condos and single homes located to the south of the Stickney Point south bridge, which may be preferred if a home buyer prefers more serenity. There are many Siesta Key real estate options, with homes ranging from the 1950’s ranchers, to multi-million dollar Gulf front estate homes. If you are looking for a vacation home, or desire full-time island living, we can help.

The maintenance-free lifestyle of Siesta Key condos may also be an attractive option. Many condos are suitable to buy as an investor, and rent throughout the year to vacationers. Several buildings offer in-house rental management services. Other condos cater to the owners who live in Siesta Key all year around, and have stricter rental policies catering to long term residents. We can help buyers navigate all the options. Buyers looking for a more residential vibe my prefer the feel of Lido Key homes, or the more gated community type of atmosphere found with Longboat Key homes.

Siesta Key Public Beaches

The main Siesta Key beach just completed a 21 million dollar renovation in 2017. The white sandy beaches of Siesta Key are world famous, earning Siesta Key the title of “Best Beach in the USA”. The white powdery sand is fine quartz and cool to the touch. Check out all the Siesta Key public beach access points. Current Siesta Key homes for sale will always be one of our most popular buyer agent searches.

The travel channel has featured Siesta key as one of Florida’s nicest vacation spots, which is evident by large numbers of yearly visitors to the area. When traveling south, visitors will find Crescent beach which also feature the famous flat beaches, yet is less crowded due to only one public access point. Continuing even further south, you will find Turtle Beach. Turtle Beach features a steeper sloping beach, with more shells and rocks, perfect for little ones who like to collect shells.

Restaurants and Shopping in Siesta Key

There are numerous beach side smaller restaurants and boutiques that pepper the streets throughout Siesta Key, and Siesta Village which is the largest hot spot. Siesta Village is located just north of the famous public beach. You will find the stores and boutiques are centrally located within the village, along with commercial businesses and residential homes. There is no major grocery store on the island of Siesta Key, however a large Publix grocery store located less than one mile from the south Siesta Key bridge on the Sarasota mainland.

Start Your Home Search With Us

Siesta Key is a fabulous hot spot for beach lovers, investors, and residents looking for a popular “beachy” atmosphere. We are full time agents, and happy to help buyers navigate all the considerations in finding their perfect slice of Siesta Key paradise.

Siesta Key Frequently Asked Questions

Siesta Key Real Estate


How big is Siesta Key?

Siesta Key is a barrier island of Sarasota, spanning 8 miles. Although the island is long, it is fairly skinny, as there are only about 2.5 total square miles of land.

Why are condos for sale in Siesta Key so popular?

Siesta Key has been rated the #1 beach in the U.S.A. according to Dr. Beach and Trip Advisor. The sugar white sand is famously known as “the world’s whitest sand”. Recently, the beach received a 21 million dollar renovation to add more concessions, additional free parking, a playground and picnic area. The island is visited by millions of people each year.

How many beaches are on Siesta Key?

There are three beaches. The northern most beach is called Siesta Beach, followed by Crescent Beach in the central area of Siesta Key. Turtle Beach is located at the southern end of Siesta Key.

Is parking free for Siesta Key Beach?

Yes! There are over 1000 free parking spaces for beach visitors.

What is the population of Siesta Key?

There are about 7200 residents in Siesta Key, however the island is visited by millions of vacationers and tourists each year.

What is there to do in Siesta Key besides going to the beach?

Siesta Key has a wide array of shopping, restaurants and bars along the 8 mile stretch of island. There are boat rentals available, fishing charters, dolphin tours, and jet ski rentals too.

What type of real estate can I find in Siesta Key?

Siesta Key has many beach condos that are situated right on the Gulf of Mexico sand. Many are used as investment vacation rental properties. There are also over 40 single family neighborhoods in Siesta Key.

Who should I contact to purchase real estate in Siesta Key?

Contact Bill & Cheryl McCue from the We Sell Sarasota Group @ Bright Realty.

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Insight For Siesta Key Homes

Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.

Siesta Key Homes in Sarasota, FL. - Beach Aerial View
Sarasota Homes Group Logo

Our Personal Siesta Key Homes Insights

Sarasota FL. Homes For Sale
"Pros" icon - Happy Face

Pros

  • Rated as the #1 beach in the USA.
  • Beach pavilion renovated, 20 new picnic shelters and additional parking added for 140
  • Many residential and investment property options
traffic jam
"Cons" icon - Indifferent Face

Considerations

  • During peak season of January – April, population / traffic increase substantially
  • Flood Risk (it’s an island)
shopping district near UTC Mall
"Shopping" icon - Shopping Bag

Shopping

  • Grocery store is 4.7 miles
  • Siesta Village is 15.9 miles
  • Nearest mall is 3.5 miles
Siesta Key Beach Residences Condos in Siesta Key, FL. - Beach
"Beach" icon - Beach and umbrella

Beach

Couple Outdoor Dining
"Lifestyle" icon - Fork & Knife

Lifestyle

  • Fun public beach vibe day and night
  • Numerous fine dining restaurants as well as many casual beach bars.
  • It’s a vacationers lifestyle on Siesta Key
One Park Condos in Downtown Sarasota, FL - Exterior of Building at Sunset
"Downtown" icon - Downtown buildings

Downtown Sarasota

  • 3.8 miles
  • 11 minute drive

Honesty · Reputation · Experience · Top 2% Sales Team in Sarasota

Sarasota Homes Group The Best Sarasota Realtors

Homes For Sale in Siesta Key

GET INSTANT

New Listing AlertS

Siesta Key Homes

  • New listings move fast
  • Instant email alerts
  • Never miss a new listing

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

Bill and Cheryl McCue - Sarasota's Best Realtors
Bill McCue, Broker Associate

Need a Siesta Key Homes real estate agent?

Bill & Cheryl McCue and their talented team are a top 2% selling team in Sarasota and Manatee County.

  • 23 years full-time experience.
  • Specializing in assisting buyers, listing & selling.
  • Market valuations for Siesta Key Homes owners.
  • 100’s of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
  • Sold over 400+ homes and counting.

Bill & Cheryl McCue

Sarasota Homes Group

Siesta Key Neighborhoods Index

Quick summary of each neighborhood

View Index

Siesta Key FL. Neighborhood Map

Map Facet: Siesta Key

Explore Siesta Key FL. Neighborhoods

Compare Siesta Key communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.

More Details

Filter by community features:

1-12 of 42 Filtered Results
  • Banyan Club Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Banyan Club

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    13

    N/A

    1979 - 1982

    8-12 Months

    1

    Amenities:

    Pool, Tennis Court, Maintenance-Free Landscaping.

    Learn More
  • Bay Island Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Bay Island

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    166

    1,500 - 8,138

    1925 - 2024

    1 Week

    52

    $1.0M-$18.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront.

    Learn More
  • Bay Island Shores Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Bay Island Shores

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    60

    2,943 - 6,827

    1952 - 2015

    1 Week

    52

    $2.4M-$7.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront.

    Learn More
  • Bayou Louise Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Bayou Louise

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    25

    N/A

    1940 - 1988

    1 Week

    52

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    Learn More
  • Blind Pass Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Blind Pass

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    12

    2,256 - 15,000

    1954 - 2010

    1 Week

    52

    $1.3M-$8.5M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    Learn More
  • Cocoanut Bayou Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Cocoanut Bayou

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    50

    3,147 - 6,838

    1950 - 2012

    No Minimum

    52

    $3.0M-$10.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    Learn More
  • Fiddler Bayou Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Fiddler Bayou

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    11

    1,700 - 8,600

    1950 - 2008

    No Minimum

    No Minimum

    $400k-$15.0M

    Amenities:

    No HOA

    Learn More
  • Gulf Water View Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Gulf Water View

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    250

    1,869 - 7,052

    1950 - 2024

    Varies

    Varies

    $500k-$3.0M

    Amenities:

    No HOA in most neighborhoods

    Learn More
  • Harmony Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Harmony

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    96

    1,930 - 5,078

    1955 - 2024

    1 Month

    12

    $995k-$4.5M

    Amenities:

    No HOA

    Learn More
  • Hidden Harbor Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Hidden Harbor

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    45

    1,358 - 8,165

    1954 - 2024

    1 Month

    12

    $1.6M-$15.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront, Deed Restrictions, Homes with Boat Docks.

    Learn More
  • Mangroves Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Mangroves

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    27

    2,567 - 3,917

    1975 - 1989

    8-12 Months

    1

    $1.1M-$3.5M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    Learn More
  • Midnight Harbor Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Midnight Harbor

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    13

    2,522 - 5,142

    1951 - 2006

    No Minimum

    No Minimum

    $1.9M-$4.5M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    Learn More
Find The Right Neighborhood

Find The Right Neighborhood Fast

  • Search by price, age, and amenities
  • View matching communities on a map
  • Compare condos and neighborhoods instantly

We are local. Your information stays private.

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

Local Real Estate Performance Reports

Is Sarasota Single Home Market Hot, or Cold?

View latest report by location.

  • Average Price & Days on Market
  • Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
  • Inventory Supply
  • Buyer or Seller Market Indicators

Current PDF Report: (opens in new window)

You May Like: