Sara Sands Homes For Sale | Siesta Key, FL

/ Neighborhoods / Sara Sands

Sara Sands Community Guide

Sara Sands: 204 homes in Siesta Key, built 1952-2024.

Search 900+ Neighborhoods & Condos By Name

Sara Sands Real Estate in Siesta Key, FL

Sara Sands homes for sale sit on the west side of Siesta Key, roughly 204 residences dating from the 1960s to present, contemporary island living with plenty of newer construction mixed among the originals. Sizes run 2,000 to over 3,900 square feet, and several stately Mediterranean estates have gone up along the canals in recent years. No gate here, and canal-front lots come with private docks, a natural draw for anyone into fishing or water sports.

Tropical landscaping wraps the community in privacy despite the central location, and Siesta Key Village sits close by for shopping and casual dining. You’re about a mile from public beach access, and downtown Sarasota is under 6 miles away, close enough for regular trips without giving up the island’s quieter pace.

Sara Sands Neighborhood Facts

5124 Higel Ave, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA

Residences: 204

Price Range:$1.0M-$3.5M
Year Built:1952 – 2023
Size (Sq. Ft.):1,898 – 3,723
Min. Lease:1 Month
Leases/ Year:12
Gated:✖ No
Pool:✖ No
Fences:✖ No
Golf Course: ✖ No
CDD Fee:✖ No

Explore Similar Neighborhoods By Feature:

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Amenities:

None

Fees Include:

No HOA.

Homes For Sale in Sara Sands

GET INSTANT

New Listing AlertS

Sara Sands

  • New listings move fast
  • Instant email alerts
  • Never miss a new listing

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

Honesty ยท Reputation ยท Experience ยท Top 2% Realtors in Sarasota

Sarasota Homes Group The Best Sarasota Realtors

Map of Sara Sands

Map showing location of Sara Sands Homes For Sale | Siesta Key,
  FL
Click to explore map

Additional Sara Sands Neighborhood Information

Sara Sands residents enjoy Siesta Key’s silky white sand, along with the ability to dolphin watch, or observe all the tropical wildlife included in the Siesta Beach experience. Siesta Key Village is nearby, offering a popular shopping area on the Key.  Neighbors can take an afternoon to browse a variety of 100+ stores, along with enjoying lunch at one of the many casual outdoor cafes. The Village has a grocery store, shops that sell souvenirs, sun gear, bars and night life with entertainment.  Downtown Sarasota is known as the cultural coast featuring artistic venues such as the Ringling Museum of Art, Van Wezel Performing Arts, Marina Jack Cruises, Sarasota Jungle Garden, stunning public art and parks.  Boaters should not miss touring the Sara Sands community.

Sara Sands Frequently Asked Questions

Sara Sands Real Estate


How large is the Sara Sands neighborhood in Siesta Key?

Sara Sands is about 204 homes, built between 1960’s – present.

Is Sara Sands in Siesta Key a gated community?

No, Sara Sands is not a gated community.

Does Sara Sands allow fences?

Yes, some homes in Sara Sands have fencing, however there may be restrictions regarding which lot locations may have a fence, or the size or type of fence allowed. It is important to check city rules for specific fencing requirements prior to making a purchase decision.

What public beach access point is closest to Sara Sands?

Sara Sands is located about 1 mile from beach access point #2 at 41 Beach Road.

How far is Sara Sands from downtown Sarasota?

Sara Sands is located about 5.7 miles from downtown Sarasota.

How far is the Sarasota International Airport from Sara Sands?

Sara Sands is located about 9.7 miles from the Sarasota International Airport.

*Accuracy of info provided is not guaranteed. All info must be verified before making a purchase decision.

Insight For Sara Sands

Learn our thoughts as professional Sarasota Realtors for the pros, cons, lifestyle, and proximity to beaches, shopping, and downtown.

Sara Sands Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.
Sarasota Homes Group Logo

Our Personal Sara Sands Insights

Sarasota FL. Homes For Sale
"Pros" icon - Happy Face

Pros

  • Convenient location
  • No HOA fees
  • Quiet streets
traffic jam
"Cons" icon - Indifferent Face

Considerations

  • Some homes are older and may need updating
shopping district near UTC Mall
"Shopping" icon - Shopping Bag

Shopping

  • Grocery store is 3.7 miles
  • Siesta Village is 1.0 miles
  • Nearest mall is 3.6 miles
Siesta Key Beach Residences Condos in Siesta Key, FL. - Beach
"Beach" icon - Beach and umbrella

Beach

Couple Outdoor Dining
"Lifestyle" icon - Fork & Knife

Lifestyle

  • Great neighborhood for boating and fishing
  • Beach vacation vibe, but quieter location
  • Both fine dining and casual beach bars within minutes
One Park Condos in Downtown Sarasota, FL - Exterior of Building at Sunset
"Downtown" icon - Downtown buildings

Downtown Sarasota

  • 5.7 miles
  • 15 minute drive

Explore Siesta Key FL. Neighborhoods

Compare Siesta Key communities by location, amenities, price, and lifestyle.

More Details

Filter by community features:

1-12 of 41 Filtered Results
  • Banyan Club Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Banyan Club

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    13

    N/A

    1979 - 1982

    8-12 Months

    1

    Amenities:

    Pool, Tennis Court, Maintenance-Free Landscaping.

    View Banyan Club Homes
  • Bay Island Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Bay Island

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    166

    1,500 - 8,138

    1925 - 2024

    1 Week

    52

    $1.0M-$18.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront.

    View Bay Island Homes
  • Bay Island Shores Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Bay Island Shores

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    60

    2,943 - 6,827

    1952 - 2015

    1 Week

    52

    $2.4M-$7.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront.

    View Bay Island Shores Homes
  • Bayou Louise Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Bayou Louise

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    25

    N/A

    1940 - 1988

    1 Week

    52

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    View Bayou Louise Homes
  • Blind Pass Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Blind Pass

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    12

    2,256 - 15,000

    1954 - 2010

    1 Week

    52

    $1.3M-$8.5M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    View Blind Pass Homes
  • Cocoanut Bayou Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Cocoanut Bayou

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    50

    3,147 - 6,838

    1950 - 2012

    No Minimum

    52

    $3.0M-$10.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    View Cocoanut Bayou Homes
  • Fiddler Bayou Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Fiddler Bayou

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    11

    1,700 - 8,600

    1950 - 2008

    No Minimum

    No Minimum

    $400k-$15.0M

    Amenities:

    No HOA

    View Fiddler Bayou Homes
  • Gulf Water View Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Gulf Water View

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    250

    1,869 - 7,052

    1950 - 2024

    Varies

    Varies

    $500k-$3.0M

    Amenities:

    No HOA in most neighborhoods

    View Gulf Water View Homes
  • Harmony Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Harmony

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    96

    1,930 - 5,078

    1955 - 2024

    1 Month

    12

    $995k-$4.5M

    Amenities:

    No HOA

    View Harmony Homes
  • Hidden Harbor Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Hidden Harbor

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    45

    1,358 - 8,165

    1954 - 2024

    1 Month

    12

    $1.6M-$15.0M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront, Deed Restrictions, Homes with Boat Docks.

    View Hidden Harbor Homes
  • Mangroves Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Mangroves

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    27

    2,567 - 3,917

    1975 - 1989

    8-12 Months

    1

    $1.1M-$3.5M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    View Mangroves Homes
  • Midnight Harbor Homes For Sale in Siesta Key, FL.

    Midnight Harbor

    Total Homes:

    Size (SqFt.):

    Year Built:

    Min. Lease:

    Leases/ Yr:

    Pricing:

    13

    2,522 - 5,142

    1951 - 2006

    No Minimum

    No Minimum

    $1.9M-$4.5M

    Amenities:

    Waterfront

    View Midnight Harbor Homes
Find The Right Neighborhood

Find The Right Neighborhood Fast

  • Search by price, age, and amenities
  • View matching communities on a map
  • Compare condos and neighborhoods instantly

We are local. Your information stays private.

We’re local. Your info stays private here.

You May Like:

Local Real Estate Performance Reports

Is Sarasota Single Home Market Hot, or Cold?

View latest report by location.

  • Average Price & Days on Market
  • Active, Sale Pending, Sold Volume
  • Inventory Supply
  • Buyer or Seller Market Indicators

Current PDF Report: (opens in new window)

Bill & Cheryl McCue - Sarasota Realtors
Bill & Cheryl McCue
Broker Associate & Realtors

(941)ย 265-0590

Buying or Selling in Sara Sands?

Your local Sara Sands real estate experts.

Bill & Cheryl McCue and the Sarasota Homes Group know Sara Sands inside and out. 23 years of experience helping buyers and sellers in this market.

  • Local Sara Sands Realtor with deep market knowledge.
  • Top 2% selling Realtors in Sarasota & Manatee County.
  • 23 years full-time experience.
  • Current listings, sold data, and market trends for this area.
  • Specializing in buying, listing, and selling homes in this market.
  • Free market valuation for owners in this area.
  • 100โ€™s of 5-star reviews on Google, Realtor.com, Zillow, Homes.com and more.
  • Sold over 500+ homes.

Bill & Cheryl McCue

Sarasota Homes Group